Why I’ll never buy another 10-inch tablet

by Dallon Christensen

I’ll be honest. I really want my stepson’s Kindle Fire (affiliate link) – or at least an Fire-sized version of an iPad.

Kindle Fire photo

My stepson Thomas received a Kindle Fire from his grandmother in April. The timing was wonderful, because Thomas was in the hospital after his initial diabetes diagnosis. I couldn’t resist the temptation and loaded some free apps to test it when he came home. While Thomas slept, I used the Fire to read books, check my RSS feeds, look at Facebook, and write some notes in Evernote. I figured I have given Thomas my iPhone enough on car trips that I could get some payback.

One of the great IT debates of the last two years has been the ideal tablet size. Apple started the craze with the iPad, which has a screen size of just under 10 inches. Some tablets are slightly bigger, some are significantly smaller, but the debate has continued. When I started playing with the Kindle Fire, my mind was made up. Despite the criticisms of some well-respected technology experts, the Kindle Fire is the right size for the real benefits of tablet computing. Michael Hyatt and Chris Brogan have also written about the beauty of a smaller tablet for content consumption.

The rumors of a 7-inch iPad “Mini” are too strong to ignore now, and I eagerly await the introduction of this device. 7-inch tablets are the right size for tablet computers for the following reasons.

  1. A 7-inch tablet is more mobile – My wife and I place our iPad in a dedicated messenger bag when we go on vacation. I have tried to place the iPad in the same bag as my MacBook Pro, and the bag becomes heavy and bulky. I have also heard several friends complain about the 10-inch iPad being awkward to transport when walking. Meanwhile, I can fit a 7-inch tablet into my laptop bag with no trouble. My wife can fit the Kindle Fire in her purse. A 7-inch tablet is simply a more portable device.
  2. It eliminates the confusion of how to use your devices – I have used my first-generation iPad as a laptop replacement two times while traveling. My friends and other conference attendees raved about my new “computer”. However, I was not as impressed with the iPad’s ability to replace my laptop. Even when I used a Bluetooth keyboard instead of the iPad’s touch screen keyboard, the device simply did not live up to my computing expectations.
  3. Mobile computers are now more portable – This point relates to point #2 above. My two-year-old MacBook Pro is the lightest and most portable laptop I have ever owned. Now that I use an iMac for my home office, I will eventually purchase a 13-inch MacBook Air. I create a great deal of content, and a laptop computer is a superior device for creating.
  4. The same features on multiple devices creates confusion – I am a heavy Evernote and Dropbox user, and I love having my content on multiple devices. However, I find myself debating when to use the iPad and when to use my laptop. I decided to simplify my IT use and use a laptop when I create any content. Before I made this decision, I would write occasionally on my iPad and occasionally on my laptop. I spent too much time deciding where to do my work and less time actually doing my work.

I love tablet computers, and they are here to stay. I just don’t want to use a tablet to create content. A smaller iPad will give me the ability to use the iPad for its intended purpose – consuming content – and maximize the benefits of these great devices. If you are buying a new tablet, what will you buy and why? Share your thoughts in the comments!

  • CarterMorgan

    I would absolutely love to have an iPad Mini. Currently I just use my iPad 2 and take it everywhere I got, and I love it but it would be great to have a smaller iPad that is more portable. I first heard about the iPad Mini from a coworker at Dish and I have been trying to find more information about it everyday. I agree with you that it’s hard to create any content on an iPad, just with how uncomfortable it can be without a keyboard, so I normally just use my iPad for streaming live TV to the Dish Remote Access app from my Sling Adapter connected DVR. I’ll also read books and play games, but it’s hard to read on it when it’s so bulky to hold. If we see a mini version of the iPad I would buy it immediately! Hopefully we will find out soon!

    • http://www.whiteboardbusiness.com/ Dallon Christensen

      Hi, Morgan,

      First of all, thanks for commenting! You and I are in complete agreement on the iPad Mini. I have a Bluetooth keyboard for when I’ve used my iPad 1 as a laptop. It works OK, but I’d still rather type with a laptop computer. Meanwhile, we’ve started to use my iPad a lot as a TV replacement. My wife watches “Vampire Diaries” on it a lot! I haven’t tested an Amazon Prime download on the Kindle yet, but I’ll do that soon.

      If an iPad Mini becomes available, it’s on the top of my Christmas list. I’d probably really limit the number of apps on it. You actually gave me a great idea for a post for the “must have” apps to have for a tablet computer. :) If I were a betting person, I would bet highly on a 7-inch iPad being introduced at the September 12 Apple event.

      I can see myself taking a MacBook Air, small iPad, and iPhone on vacation. I can’t see myself taking a MBA and a 10-inch iPad. There’s just too much similarity in size and ease of transport.

  • Barrett Young

    I been saying, Dallon! I’ve been lauding the Fire for months, and you doubted. Nice to see you’ve converted.

    Good points, but I differ on your conclusion. When I move “up” from my Fire (if I do), I’ll go with the Nexus 7. But I’m an android user, so your choice makes sense for you.

    On content creation though, I actually write a large majority of my blog posts on my Fire. I save them in draft mode and edit them on the desktop before they’re published, but I like that I can write a post wherever I feel so inspired.

    I watch movies on it all the time. Same with Amazon MP3s, and Pandora. I still have yet to read magazines on it, though I don’t get many magazines that I end up reading.

    It would be nice if they’d release a native Buffer app for the Fire, since that’s where I read all my feeds. Right now, I have to mark them “Leave unread” and then go buffer them later.

    7″ is the best size. Mine is in my back pocket or jacket pocket every single day.

    • http://www.whiteboardbusiness.com/ Dallon Christensen

      Barrett, I’ll be the first to admit I was dead wrong about the 7-inch tablet! I’ve heard outstanding reviews on the Nexus 7. Leo LaPorte of This Week in Tech and MacBreak Weekly raves about the Nexus. If I used Android, I’d use that one. In fact, if I’m not a fan of the iPad Mini for whatever reason, I’ll give the Nexus a close look. The reason I’m hooked on Apple is because of the ecosystem around it. I really like using cross-platform Mac apps like DayOne (my journaling application) and Priority Matrix (my project planning application). The one thing I’ll still do on a 7-inch tablet is update Evernote. I have a checklist of blog ideas and a notebook full of blog idea templates (I stole this idea from Michael Hyatt). I know I could easily do that on any 7-inch tablet.

Previous post:

Next post: